State Rep. David Willis wants Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools split into smaller districts and a recall vote on the school board. He said a breakup would take years.
The chairman of the state House’s K-12 education committee wants Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools broken up into smaller districts. He also wants voters to get a recall vote on the current school board.
State Rep. David Willis, R-Union County, set out both ideas Wednesday in an interview with WBT radio host Brett Jensen. He said a breakup would take years. No bill on either idea has been filed.
“I think there is a too big to succeed model out there and we found it,” Willis said.
Willis represents House District 68 in Union County, which borders Mecklenburg County. He leads the House K-12 education committee and the House education budget committee, according to his General Assembly committee page.
What Willis said
Willis said his office had given school board members his email address and about a week and a half to send in comments. “We felt like it was important as we move forward with this, that they at least be given an opportunity to provide their thoughts and input on it,” he said.
On a breakup, he said:
- it is “way too early” to say how many districts CMS might become
- it would be “a multi-year process” bringing in local and state leaders, educators and communities to study the right size for a district
- he hopes to start naming the people for those talks, and start the talks, before the end of the year
“Anybody that’s hearing this and thinking about, oh, my gosh, the school is going to get broken up, where are we going to be? … I would just say, relax,” Willis said. “This is going to be a multi-year approach.”
He said CMS is about four times the size of Union County’s school system, and that the district stretches from Cornelius and Huntersville to Steele Creek, Ballantyne and Matthews. When storms hit part of the county, he said, the whole district has to close.
On a recall, he said: “We’ve clearly lost public trust in the school board.” He said parents should be able “to elect new school board members to really right the ship.” He added that he would look at “all of our options and how quickly we can make that happen.”
Willis also said he “would very much approve of the state stepping in and taking over financial control immediately,” citing the state’s recent move in Winston-Salem.
On his X account, Willis wrote: “CMS leadership is in shambles.” He added: “I think it’s time for a task force to look at breaking up CMS.”
Why now
The Charlotte-Mecklenburg Board of Education voted 5-4 on Sept. 22 to end Crystal Hill’s employment as superintendent, according to the board’s statement that night. Melissa Balknight is acting superintendent.
The board and the district said in a Sept. 28 statement that they are cooperating with the Office of the State Auditor and the State Bureau of Investigation. In an Oct. 2 statement, they said they welcome a review of those investigations by the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction.
Willis said the investigations weighed “significantly” in his thinking.
The board had not posted a statement on Willis’s proposal in its media room as of Thursday afternoon.
The state looked at this in 2018
Breaking up CMS is not a new idea. In 2017 the General Assembly set up a joint study committee on dividing large school districts. Its final report, adopted April 11, 2018, found:
- studies did “not document a relationship” between a district’s size and how well its students do, though smaller schools appeared to help
- dividing a district could reduce equality in buildings, programs and teacher quality
- any law letting citizens start the breakup of a large district “will require additional study”
The committee listed questions it did not have time to answer. They included how an interim board would work, whether voters should get a referendum and how a permanent board would be chosen. Past mergers approved by the General Assembly took six months to two years to put in place, legislative staff told the committee.
What happens next
The state House convenes at noon Monday, Nov. 16, according to the General Assembly’s calendar. Any change to how CMS is organized or governed would need a law passed by the General Assembly.
CMS has about 140,000 students in 185 schools and facilities, according to the district, and is the second-largest school district in North Carolina.
What it means for you
- Nothing changes for students now. No bill has been filed. Willis said a breakup would take years.
- Your state representative will vote on any bill. Find yours with the General Assembly’s Find Your Legislators search. Willis asked parents, students and staff to contact their local and state officials.
- To reach Willis, use his General Assembly contact page.
- To reach the school board, use the board’s contact page.
Have your say